Skip to main content
Close navigation menu
CJ'S Sandwich Institution, Homepage
Navigation menu Close navigation menu

Italian-American Flavors

Our Menu

Dig into toasted subs, loaded fries, pizzas and more at CJ'S Sandwich Institution in Geneva, NY.

Order Pickup (opens in new tab) View Printable Menu (PDF) (opens in new tab)

Toasted Subs

Prices listed as Regular / Grande.

  • Gluten Free Roll Add $2
  • Add Long Hots or Cherry Peppers $2

  • Chicken Alla Vodka Parm

    Chicken Cutlets, Fresh Mozzarella, Vodka Sauce, Pesto

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22
    • Add Cup ‘n’ Char Pepperoni, Regular $2, Grande $1

  • Nonnie’s Hand Rolled Meatballs

    Veal, Pork, Beef, Fresh Mozzarella, Shaved Parmesan

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Chicken Parmesan

    Chicken Cutlets, Marinara, Fresh Mozzarella, Shaved Parmesan, Fresh Basil

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Eggplant Parmesan

    Fried Eggplant, Marinara, Fresh Mozzarella, Shaved Parmesan, Fresh Basil

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Sunday Feast

    Rigatoni, Bolognese Sauce, Meatballs, Fresh Mozzarella, Shaved Parmesan, Garlic Butter

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Chopped Cheese

    16 oz. Brisket Burger, American Cheese, Onions, CJ’s Burger Sauce

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • PittsBurger

    16 oz. Hand Packed Brisket Burger, American Cheese, Coleslaw, Tomatoes, Shoe String Fries, CJ’s Burger Sauce

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Sloppy JOEgie

    Sloppy Joe, Pepper Jack, Fried Onions, Shoe String Fries

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Grandpa’s Fried Bologna

    Fried Bologna, Fried Pepperoni, Roasted Reds, Mozzarella

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Thanksgiving

    Honey Roasted Turkey, Stuffing, Gravy, Fried Onion Strings, Cranberry Aïoli, More Gravy

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Nonnie’s Pot Roast

    Slow Roasted Chuck Roast, PepperJack, Shoe String Fries

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Coach Tuna

    Tuna, Provolone, Cherry Peppers, Lettuce, Pickles, Onion, Hot Pepper Relish, EVOO, Vinegar, Salt & Pepper, Oregano, Garlic Aïoli

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Union Ave Caprese

    Burrata, Pesto Ricotta, Charred Cherry Tomato Confit, Balsamic Glaze

    • Regular $15
    • Grande $22

  • Chicken and Cheese Philly

    Shaved Chicken Breast, Grilled Onions & Peppers, Provolone, Shredded Lettuce, Garlic Aïoli

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Johnny Roast Beef

    Shaved Beef, Mozzarella, Caramelized Onions, Garlic Butter, Au Jus

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Bucky’s 27

    Shaved Roast Beef, Swiss, Lettuce, Onions, Banana Peppers, Garlic Aïoli

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Fanucci

    Chicken & Eggplant Cutlets, Crispy Proscuitto, Marinara, Fresh Mozzarella, Herbed Pesto Ricotta

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • French Dip

    Shaved beef, provolone, caramelized onion, au Jus

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

Cold Subs

Prices listed as Regular / Grande.

  • Gluten Free Roll Add $2
  • Add Long Hots or Cherry Peppers $2

  • Seneca Crunch Hero

    Honey Roasted Turkey, Salami, Soppressata, Hot Pepper Relish, Provolone, Pickles, Cheddar Chips, Spicy Mustard, Garlic Aïoli, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, EVOO, Vinegar, Oregano

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Sinatra

    Mortadella, Hot Capicola, Soppressata, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Balsamic Glaze, EVOO, Salt & Pepper

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Godfather

    Chicken Cutlets, Blistered Cherry Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella, Pesto Herbed Ricotta, Balsamic Glaze, EVOO

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Pentangeli

    Chicken Cutlets, Soppressata, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Caramelized Onions, Hot Honey, Chipotle Aïoli

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Corleone

    Eggplant Cutlets, Crispy Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Cherry Tomato Confit, Pesto, EVOO, Balsamic Glaze

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Italian Stallion

    Mortadella, Hot Capicola, Salami, Soppressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, EVOO, Vinegar, Oregano

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • All American

    Honey Roasted Turkey, Hot Capicola, Provolone, American Cheese, Cherry Peppers, Pickles, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, EVOO, Vinegar, Salt & Pepper, Oregano

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • CJ’s Special

    Mortadella, Salami, Hot Capicola, Soppressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Hot Pepper Relish, Salt & Pepper, EVOO, Balsamic Glaze

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Windy City

    Shaved Beef, Fried Peppers, Hot Giardiniera, Au Jus, Baptized

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Nashville Hot

    Chicken Cutlets, Hot Sauce, Fried Mac ‘n’ Cheese Balls, Coleslaw, Pickles

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Mild Buffalo Chicken Caesar

    Chicken Cutlets, Romaine Lettuce, Wing Sauce, Shaved Parmesan, Crispy Prosciutto, Caesar Dressing, Garlic Butter Roll

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • TPJ Club

    Honey Roasted Turkey, Pepper Jack, Bacon, Avocado, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, EVOO, Vinegar, Oregano, Garlic Aïoli

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • CBR

    Chicken Cutlets, Monterey Jack, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Hot Honey Ranch

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

  • Bacon & More Bacon BLT

    Bacon, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Hot Honey, Garlic Aïoli

    • Regular $16
    • Grande $22

Paninis

Served With French Fries

  • Substitute House Salad $4
  • Substitute Soup $4

  • Tuna

    $16

    Swiss, Cherry Peppers, White Albacore Tuna

  • Smash Burger

    $16

    ½ lb Angus Chuck, American Cheese, Caramelized Onion, Smash Sauce

  • Spicy Roast Beef

    $16

    In-House Slow-Roasted Beef, Swiss Cheese, Caramelized Onion, Horseradish Aïoli

  • Pot Roast

    $16

    Aged NY Cheddar, Crispy Onions, Au Jus

  • Turkey

    $16

    House Roasted Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Bacon, Avocado, Tomato, Garlic Aïoli

  • Bourdain’s Favorite

    $16

    Grilled Mortadella, Provolone, Mayo, Spicy Mustard

  • Dr. Pepper Short Rib & Mac

    $20

    Dr. Pepper Braised Short Rib, Cheddar Mac & Cheese, Caramelized Onion, Au Jus

  • Italian Grilled Cheese

    $16

    Mortadella, soppressata, capicola, provolone, cherry pepper relish

The Fries

House Made Onion Rings

with CJ’s Sauce

$12

  • Steak Fries

    $20

    Grilled Stockyard, Mushrooms, Mozzarella, Caramelized Onions, Chimichurri, Horseradish Garlic Aïoli

  • Smash Burger Fries

    $17

    2 Cheeseburgers, Onions, Pickles, Smash Sauce

  • Sloppy Joe Fries

    $16

    Sloppy Joe, Fried Onions, Pepper Jack Cheese, Chipotle Aïoli

  • Nashville Hot Fries

    $18

    Hot Chicken Cutlets, Mac and Cheese Balls, Pickles, Coleslaw, Nashville Hot Sauce

  • Pot Roast Fries

    $18

    Slow Roasted Chuck, Pepper Jack Cheese, Fried Onions

  • Cantina Fries

    $18

    Monterey Jack Cheese, Pickled Jalapeños, Sour Cream, Green Chili Sauce, Scallions

  • Buffalo Fries

    $18

    Buffalo Chicken Cutlets, Monterey Jack Cheese, Wing Sauce, Hot Honey Ranch, Scallions

  • Alfredo Fries

    $14

    Bacon, Asiago, Scallions

  • Smashless Fries

    $14

    Smash Sauce, Crumbly Bacon, Scallions

The Tots

  • Heluva Tots

    $18

    Monterey Jack, Crumbled Bacon, Heluva Good Onion Dip, Green Onions

  • Jack ‘n’ Tots

    $18

    Jack Daniel’s Chicken Cutlets, Monterey Jack Cheese, Green Onion, Chipotle Aïoli

  • Mac ‘n’ Tots

    $18

    Fried Mac and Cheese Balls, Monterey Jack Cheese, Crumbled Bacon, Green Onion, Vodka Sauce Shooter

Wings & Things

  • Wings

    • 10 for $18
    • 20 for $34

  • Wing Flite

    $19

    Plain wings with choice of 4 C.J.’s Sauces: Mild, Med, Hot, Spicy Thai Raspberry, Chipotle Pineapple, Hot Honey Lemon Pepper, Cajun Honey Butter, Old Bay, C.J.’S Tiger Sauce, Spicy Guinness Gold, Jack Daniels, Spicy Bourbon, Hawaiian Teriyaki, Japanese Sesame BBQ Jalapeño

  • Chips & Salsa with Queso

    $10

  • Cheesy Garlic Bread

    $10

  • Homemade Mozzarella Logs

    $13

    with vodka red sauce

  • Fried Shrimp

    $14

    with Thai raspberry sauce

  • Giant Pretzel on the Hook

    $15

14 Inch Pizzas

  • Cheese Pizza

    $17

  • Char ‘n’ Cup & Cheese

    $19

  • Vodka Sauce, Char ‘n’ Cup & Cherry Peppers

    $20

    Vodka Sauce Char ‘N’ Cup, Jalapeños, Hot Honey

Add your own toppings

$2

Char ‘N’ Cup, Peppers, Onions, Jalapeños, Cherry Peppers, Mushrooms, Sausage, Ricotta, Hot Honey, Vodka Sauce

Burrito Bar

Served With Chips & Salsa

  • Blackened Chicken Chipotle

    $18

    Blackened Chicken, Monterey Jack, Peppers, Onions, Rice, Beans, Guacamole, Queso, Pico

  • The New Yorker Burrito

    $18

    Carne Asada, Spicy Fries, Peppers, Onions, Guacamole, Sour Cream, Queso

Salads and Soups

  • Nonnie’s 246

    $16

    Greens, Shaved Red Onion, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Croutons, Italian Vinaigrette

    • Chicken Cutlets $3

  • Italian Chopped

    $18

    Greens, Ham, Soppressata, Salami, Provolone, Bacon, Red Onions, Pickles, Vinegar Peppers, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Hot Pepper Relish, Jalapeños, Italian Vinaigrette

  • Cowgirl Caviar

    $18

    Greens, Chick Peas, Black Eyed Peas, Jalapeños, Tomatoes, Avocado, Red Onion, Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Cilantro, Parsley, Fresh Lime Juice

  • Antipasto

    $18

    Romaine, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Roasted Reds, Chickpeas, Giardiniera, Pepperoncini, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone, House Vinaigrette

  • Chopped Chicken Caesar

    $18

    Romaine, Parmesan, Sesame Crusted Croutons, Cutlets, House Made Caesar

  • Dorito Taco Salad

    $18

    Romaine, Seasoned Taco Beef, Crunchy Doritos, Cheddar Jack Cheese, Black Beans, Tomatoes, Red and Green Onion, Jalapeños, Sour Cream

  • Minestrone Soup

    $9

  • Soup du Jour

    $9

  • Soup and House Salad

    $15

Keto Bowls

  • Philly Bowl

    $20

    Steak or Chicken, bell peppers, mushrooms, onions, cauliflower rice, roasted garlic, mozzarella, green onion, au jus

  • Chicken Chipotle Bowl

    $20

    Adobo rubbed chicken, cheddar jack cheese, avocado, cauliflower rice, sour cream, pico de gallo, lime

  • Sesame Teriyaki Salmon

    $20

    Cauliflower Rice, Avocado, Cucumber, Tomato, Teriyaki Glaze

  • Chicago Pizza Bowl

    $14

    Ricotta, mozzarella, sauce, pepperoni, onions, and peppers

Sides

  • Loaded Potato Salad

    $7

  • Fries

    $8

  • Tomato Cucumber Salad

    $6

  • Mac Salad

    $6

  • Mac ‘n’ Cheese Bites

    $8

  • Pasta Salad

    $7

  • Tater Tots

    $10

Sweets

  • Coffee

    $3

  • Cannoli

    $7

  • Coffee & Cannoli

    $10

  • Shake of the Day

    $10

  • Hot Fudge Sundae

    $10

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae

    $10

No separate checks, please. Parties of 6 or more subject to gratuity.

Visit our sister restaurants: eddieobriens.com • fornoonseneca.com

Please notify your server if anyone in your party has a food allergy.

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.